top of page
  • Writer's pictureLizé Groenewald

Why you should never top a tree

Topping is a common, but destructive, practice in which large branches or the entire crown of a tree are removed, leaving only a few stubs or lateral branches. Some people believe that topping is required to control a tree's height or spread or to stimulate new growth. Tree experts, on the other hand, agree that topping is never a good idea and can cause irreversible damage to the tree and surrounding environment.

Here are some reasons why you should never top a tree:

It can cause significant structural damage to the tree.

When a tree is topped, its natural shape and balance are lost, which can result in weak and unstable branches that are prone to breaking. The large wounds caused by topping heal slowly, making the tree susceptible to pests, diseases, and decay. Furthermore, topping can cause an overgrowth of shoots from stubs, which are weakly attached and easily break off in wind or storms.

It may make the tree less appealing and valuable.

Topping a tree can detract from its natural beauty and aesthetics, making it appear more like a disfigured stump than a living organism. This can reduce your home's or business's property value and curb appeal, as well as detract from the overall visual appeal of your landscape. Furthermore, topping can increase maintenance and cleanup work because stubs and shoots must be pruned and removed on a regular basis.

It has the potential to harm the surrounding environment and wildlife.

Trees are more than just pretty ornaments or shade providers; they play an important role in ecosystem maintenance and biodiversity support. When a tree is cut down, it destroys the natural habitat and food sources of birds, insects, and other wildlife that rely on it for shelter, nesting, and foraging. Topping can also cause soil erosion, runoff, and nutrient depletion, all of which can have an impact on the health and fertility of the surrounding vegetation.

There are more effective alternatives to tree topping.

There are safer and more effective methods for controlling the height or spread of a tree, as well as addressing any structural or safety concerns, than topping. One option is to prune the tree selectively, removing only dead, diseased, or damaged branches and shaping the tree to keep its natural form and balance. Another option is to support the tree's weak or vulnerable branches with a cable or bracing system or to use a reduction pruning technique to gradually reduce the size of the canopy.

To summarize, while topping a tree may appear to be a quick and easy solution to a problem, it can cause more harm than good in the long run. You can help preserve the health, beauty, and value of your trees while also contributing to a healthier and more sustainable environment by avoiding topping and using more responsible tree care practices. If you want to know more about responsible tree care practices, visit our Instagram page on this link.



bottom of page